Chronic Toxicity of Detoxified Kraft Pulp and Paper Mill Wastewater using Photocatalytic with Cu-TiO2 Foils/Sunlight on Xenopus levies (daudin) Tadpoles

B. O. Orori, F. O. Odipo, M. M. Mwamburi


Wastewater from pulp and paper mills contain refractory toxic substances with deleterious effects to aquatic organisms when discharged before proper treatment. Most of the effluent treatment technologies used by the industry are predominantly inefficient, resulting in inadequate detoxification. The use of photocatalytic techniques has shown higher effluent treatment potential. However, there is need to evaluate their chronic toxicity reduction. The current study evaluated the chronic effects of detoxified Kraft pulp and paper effluent using photocatalytic on African clawed frogs (Xenopus levies) tadpoles. Chorionic toxicity was carried out according to the standard Amphibian Metamorphosis Assay (AMA) test for 21 days. Chronic toxicity of photocatalytic combined with photovoltaic (PHCPVC); photocatalytic combined with wood ash leachate as an electrolyte (PHCASH); photocatalytic alone (PHCALON); and photo-treatment without Cu-TiO2 foils (PHOALON) were studied. No Effect Concentration from the Control (NOEC) and Lowest Concentration with an Effect from the Control (LOEC), obtained in the FETAX study were used to evaluate chronic toxicity of the various photocatalytic treatment methods. The study revealed that the most effective photocatalytic treatment was PHCPVC followed by PHCALON, then PHCASH and lastly PHOALON treatment for both Kraft pulp mill effluent (PME) and biologically treated pulp and paper mill effluent (BPPME). PHCPVC reduced average mortality and malformation of tadpoles by 26% and 22% respectively. PHCPVC treatment reduced growth retardation of tadpoles by an average of 18%. Therefore, the study recommends the treatment of Kraft pulp mill effluent by PHCPVC.


Chronic Toxicity, Kraft Pulp and Paper, Photovoltaic, Photocatalytic, Xenopus Levies, Effluent Detoxification

Full Text:



Amor, C., Marchão, L., Lucas, M. S. & Peres, J. A. (2019). Application of Advanced Oxidation Processes for the Treatment of Recalcitrant Agro-Industrial Wastewater: A Review. Water, 11(2), 205.

Bantle, J. (1995). FETAX—A developmental toxicity assay using frog embryos. Fundamentals of Aquatic Toxicology, 207-230.

Bantle, J. A. & Sabourin, T. (1991). Standard guide for conducting the frog embryo teratogenesis assay-Xenopus (FETAX). American Society for Testing and Materials E1439, 91.

Basu, N., Ta, C. A., Waye, A., Mao, J., Hewitt, M., Arnason, J. T. & Trudeau, V. L. (2009). Pulp and paper mill effluents contain neuroactive substances that potentially disrupt neuroendocrine control of fish reproduction. Environmental Science & Technology, 43(5), 1635-1641.

Chandra, R., Sharma, P., Yadav, S., & Tripathi, S. (2018). Biodegradation of Endocrine-Disrupting Chemicals and Residual Organic Pollutants of Pulp and Paper Mill Effluent by Biostimulation. Frontiers in Microbiology, 9.

Chandra, R. & Singh, R. (2012). Decolourisation and detoxification of rayon grade pulp paper mill effluent by mixed bacterial culture isolated from pulp paper mill effluent polluted site. Biochemical Engineering Journal, 61, 49-58.

Chiang, G., McMaster, M. E., Urrutia, R., Saavedra, M. F., Gavilán, J., Tucca, F. . . . Munkittrick, K. R. (2011). Health status of native fish (Percilia gillissi and Trichomycterus areolatus) downstream of the discharge of effluent from a tertiary‐treated elemental chlorine‐free pulp mill in Chile. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 30(8), 1793-1809.

Crini, G. & Lichtfouse, E. (2019). Advantages and disadvantages of techniques used for wastewater treatment. Environmental Chemistry Letters, 17(1), 145-155.

Del Moro, G., Mancini, A., Mascolo, G. & Di Iaconi, C. (2013). Comparison of UV/H2O2 based AOP as an end treatment or integrated with biological degradation for treating landfill leachates. Chemical Engineering Journal, 218, 133-137.

DeVito, J. (2003). Metamorphic synchrony and aggregation as antipredator responses in American toads. Oikos, 103(1), 75-80.

Dey, S., Choudhury, M. D. & Das, S. (2013). A review on toxicity of paper mill effluent on fish. Bull. Environ. Pharmacol. Life Sci, 2, 17-23.

Goyer, R. A. (1997). Toxic and essential metal interactions. Annual Review of Nutrition, 17(1), 37-50.

Haq, I., Kumar, S., Raj, A., Lohani, M. & Satyanarayana, G. (2017). Genotoxicity assessment of pulp and paper mill effluent before and after bacterial degradation using Allium cepa test. Chemosphere, 169, 642-650.

Haq, I. & Raj, A. (2020). Pulp and Paper Mill Wastewater: Ecotoxicological Effects and Bioremediation Approaches for Environmental Safety. Bioremediation of Industrial Waste for Environmental Safety (pp. 333-356): Springer.

Kamali, M., Alavi-Borazjani, S. A., Khodaparast, Z., Khalaj, M., Jahanshahi, A., Costa, E. & Capela, I. (2019). Additive and Additive-Free Treatment Technologies for Pulp and Paper Mill Effluents: Advances, Challenges and Opportunities. Water Resources and Industry, 100109.

Kamali, M., Gomes, A. P. D., Khodaparast, Z. & Seifi, T. (2016). Review on Recent Advances in Environmental Remediation and Related Toxicity of Engineered Nanoparticles. Environmental Engineering & Management Journal (EEMJ), 15(4), 923-934.

Lindholm-Lehto, P. C., Knuutinen, J. S., Ahkola, H. S. & Herve, S. H. (2015). Refractory organic pollutants and toxicity in pulp and paper mill wastewaters. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 22(9), 6473-6499.

Malik, M., Kumar, P., Seth, R. & Rishi, S. (2009). Genotoxic effect of paper mill effluent on chromosomes of fish Channa punctatus. Current World Environment, 4(2), 353-357.

Massawe, S., Olorunnisola, A. & Adenikinju, A. (2016). The Environmental Challenges of Biomass Utilisation for Combined Heat and Power Generation in a Paper Mill in Tanzania. J Fundam Renewable Energy Appl, 6(202), 2.

Micheletto, J., Sampaio, N. M. F. M., Ruiz, H. Z., Martins, L. R. R., Liz, M. V. d. & Freitas, A. M. d. (2019). Acute ecotoxicity on Daphnia magna to evaluate effluent samples of Kraft pulp mill treated by UV/H2O2 process. Revista Ambiente & Água, 14(2). e2208.

Mishra, A., Tripathi, C., Dwivedi, A. & Dubey, V. (2011). Acute toxicity and behavioral response of freshwater fish, Mystus vittatus exposed to pulp mill effluent. Journal of Environmental Chemistry and Ecotoxicology, 3(6), 167-172.

Nieuwkoop, P. D. & Faber, J. (1994). Normal table of Xenopus laevis (Daudin): A Systematical and Chronological Survey of the Development from the Fertilized Egg till the end of Metamorphosis.

OECD. (2004). Detailed Review Paper (DRP) on Amphibian metamorphosis Assay for the Detection of Thyroid Active Substances No. 46. In (Vol. 17, pp. 106). Paris: Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development.

Oliveira, G., Calisto, V., Santos, S. M., Otero, M. & Esteves, V. I. (2018). Paper pulp-based adsorbents for the removal of pharmaceuticals from wastewater: A novel approach towards diversification. Science of The Total Environment, 631, 1018-1028.

Oller, I., Malato, S. & Sánchez-Pérez, J. (2011). Combination of advanced oxidation processes and biological treatments for wastewater decontamination—a review. Science of the total environment, 409(20), 4141-4166.

Orrego, R., Hewitt, L. M., McMaster, M., Chiang, G., Quiroz, M., Munkittrick, K. . . . Barra, R. (2019). Assessing wild fish exposure to ligands for sex steroid receptors from pulp and paper mill effluents in the Biobio River Basin, Central Chile. Ecotoxicology and environmental safety, 171, 256-263.

Osano, O. (2002). Developmental Disorders Induced by Pesticide Degradation Products. Universiteit van Amsterdam [Host].

Peitz, C. & Xavier, C. R. (2017). Treatment by moving bed biofilm reactor of Kraft effluent containing phytosterols. Interciencia, 42(8), 536-541.

Pérez, T., Garcia-Segura, S., El-Ghenymy, A., Nava, J. L. & Brillas, E. (2015). Solar photoelectro-Fenton degradation of the antibiotic metronidazole using a flow plant with a Pt/air-diffusion cell and a CPC photoreactor. Electrochimica Acta, 165, 173-181.

Rasalingam, S., Peng, R. & Koodali, R. T. (2014). Removal of hazardous pollutants from wastewaters: applications of TiO 2-SiO 2 mixed oxide materials. Journal of Nanomaterials, 2014, 10.

Savage, W. K., Quimby, F. W. & DeCaprio, A. P. (2002). Lethal and sublethal effects of polychlorinated biphenyls on Rana sylvatica tadpoles. Environmental toxicology and chemistry, 21(1), 168-174.

Schneider, J., Bahnemann, D., Ye, J., Puma, G. L. & Dionysiou, D. D. (2016). Photocatalysis: fundamentals and perspectives: Royal Society of Chemistry.

Singh, A. K. & Chandra, R. (2019). Pollutants released from the pulp paper industry: Aquatic toxicity and their health hazards. Aquatic toxicology.

Siphiwe, M. (2007). Teratogenicity of whole pulp and paper mill effluent on endemic Xenopus Laevis in river Nzoia, Kenya. (MPhil), Moi University, Unpublished.

Sutton, J. & Olomi, D. (2012). An enterprise map of Tanzania (Vol. 3): International Growth Centre in association with the London Publishing Partnership.

Tyor, A. K., Fulia, A. & Sharma, R. (2012a). Anomalies in Cyprinus carpio larvae exposed to paper mill effluent. J Biol Sci, 12, 321-326.

Tyor, A. K., Fulia, A. & Sharma, R. (2012b). Impact of paper mill effluent on the survival and hatchability of eggs of Cyprinus carpio. Research Journal of Environmental Toxicology, 6(2), 33.

van den Heuvel, M. R. (2010). Recent progress in understanding the causes of endocrine disruption related to pulp and paper mill effluents. Water Quality Research Journal of Canada, 45(2), 137-144.

Waye, A., Annal, M., Tang, A., Picard, G., Harnois, F., Guerrero-Analco, J. A. & MacLatchy, D. L. (2014). Canadian boreal pulp and paper feedstocks contain neuroactive substances that interact in vitro with GABA and dopaminergic systems in the brain. Science of the total environment, 468, 315-325.

Weber-Scannell, P. K. & Duffy, L. K. (2007). Effects of total dissolved solids on aquatic organism: a review of literature and recommendation for salmonid species. Paper presented at the American Journal of Environmental Sciences.

Zahrim, A., Gilbert, M. L. & Janaun, J. (2007). Treatment of Pulp and Paper МШ effluent using photo-Fenton’s process. J. Appl. Sci., 7, 2164-2167.

Zainith, S., Chowdhary, P. & Bharagava, R. N. (2019). Recent advances in physico-chemical and biological techniques for the management of pulp and paper mill waste. In Emerging and Eco-Friendly Approaches for Waste Management (pp. 271-297): Springer.


  • There are currently no refbacks.

© 2015 School of Environmental Studies all rights reserved. Permission should be sought from the publishers before any of this work or part of it is reproduced, transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system.